He said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” Simon Peter replied, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.”
— Matthew 16:15–16 (ESV)
The jeweler’s test
Around AD 180, a pastor in Gaul named Irenaeus set out to answer teachers who were drawing people away from the faith. First he borrowed a saying about jewelry from an earlier writer (“one far superior to me,” he called him):
“A clever imitation in glass casts contempt, as it were, on that precious jewel the emerald (which is most highly esteemed by some), unless it come under the eye of one able to test and expose the counterfeit.”
— quoted by Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1, Preface 2
Notice what worries Irenaeus. It isn’t that people will admire glass. It’s that the glass will make the real emerald look cheap. A counterfeit Christ does that to the real Christ.
This series is a jeweler’s test. Over five parts we hold four old counterfeit Christs, and one modern trap, up to the light:
- The Secret Christ (this part): the Jesus only insiders get.
- The Split Christ: Jesus, minus the God who made the world.
- True Facts, Missing Christ: when a true history, even of the Bible itself, is told so that Christ drops out.
- The Bodiless Christ: a Savior for whom flesh doesn’t matter.
- The Self-Awakening Christ: you save yourself by waking up.
Each counterfeit first appeared in the second century among teachers we now loosely call “Gnostics,” from the Greek gnōsis, “knowledge.” The label is debated: Michael Williams (Rethinking “Gnosticism,” 1996) and Karen King (What Is Gnosticism?, 2003) have shown it was never one tidy movement. And because Irenaeus was a hostile witness, we let the ancient texts speak for themselves wherever we can.
First, a mirror. The pastor Philip J. Lee used “gnostic” for the inward, private faith he saw among Protestants (Against the Protestant Gnostics, 1987). The literary critic Harold Bloom, writing not as an orthodox believer, argued in The American Religion (1992) that America’s homegrown faith is Gnostic at heart. He devoted three chapters to one of the nation’s largest evangelical denominations. You don’t have to agree with either man to hear the warning: these counterfeits aren’t only “out there.”
Why this matters now
Historian Mark Noll’s America’s Book: The Rise and Decline of a Bible Civilization, 1794–1911 (Oxford, 2022) is a rich, careful history of how the Bible shaped American public life, well worth your time, and it carries a caution for us. Here is Noll on the 1830s and 1840s:
“Although American culture in the 1830s and 1840s was not as chaotic as fifty years earlier, it remained manifestly fragile. Scripture—open to all without academic distinction, interpreted commonsensically, and functioning as an all-purpose authority—remained the essential moral guide for a civilization in constant motion.”
— Mark Noll, America’s Book, ch. 17, p. 368
An open Bible was a good gift. But abolitionists and slaveholders, reformers and end-times date-setters all claimed that same Bible for opposite ends, and no one had a shared way to settle the dispute. By the Civil War the strain had become a break:
“For the Bible, the war and North-South controversy signaled the end of a civilization premised on white Protestant scriptural agreement. If the decline of the nation’s Bible civilization was not the same as the decline of the Bible in America, it did occasion a host of new relationships involving Scripture and the nation’s cities, citizens, industries, learning, racial divides, laws, political configurations, and expressions of civil religion.”
— Mark Noll, America’s Book, ch. 22, p. 473
“If the Bible retained a considerable public presence through generations after 1865, the displacement of Protestant Scripture from its once central position had well and truly begun.”
— Mark Noll, America’s Book, ch. 22, p. 473
Notice his care: the Bible didn’t fail; a culture’s shared, commonsense way of using it broke down.
Yet Scripture’s answer to misuse is never a hidden Bible: “The secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things that are revealed belong to us and to our children forever, that we may do all the words of this law” (Deut 29:29, ESV). Look at who the revealed things belong to: us and our children. Revelation is a family inheritance, not a guild secret: the exact opposite of the first counterfeit.
The case file: the Secret Christ
Let’s do what a good Bible student does and observe before we interpret. What do the texts say?
The Secret Book of John (the Apocryphon of John) was found among the Nag Hammadi codices in Egypt in 1945. It opens by promising “the revelation of the mysteries and the things hidden in silence.” It ends with John being told to write it all down and “give them secretly to your fellow spirits, for this is the mystery of the immovable race.”
The Gospel of Thomas, from the same find, begins: “These are the secret sayings which the living Jesus spoke and which Didymos Judas Thomas wrote down.” Its first saying adds: “Whoever finds the interpretation of these sayings will not experience death.” Scholars debate how “Gnostic” Thomas is, but the shape is plain.
The Gospel of Judas, published by National Geographic in 2006, opens: “The secret account of the revelation that Jesus spoke in conversation with Judas Iscariot during a week three days before he celebrated Passover.” In it, Jesus takes Judas aside: “Step away from the others and I shall tell you the mysteries of the kingdom” (Kasser, Meyer and Wurst trans.).
Irenaeus describes his opponents the same way. They drew people away “under a pretence of [superior] knowledge… as if, forsooth, they had something more excellent and sublime to reveal” (Against Heresies 1, Preface 1).
Together they show three marks:
- There’s a hidden layer beneath the public faith.
- Only an inner circle gets it.
- Getting it is what saves you.
Where the pattern shows up today
The pattern never went away. It just changes clothes.
In the scholarship and the bookstore. The Princeton scholar Elaine Pagels brought these texts to a wide audience. Her sympathetic reading in The Gnostic Gospels (1979) won the National Book Award, and she deserves to be read fairly. Her own summary of why the Gnostic voices were lost: “It is the winners who write history—their way.” In her account, the orthodox majority shaped the record.
Other scholars, writing for general readers, have pushed back:
- Darrell Bock’s The Missing Gospels (2006) sets these texts side by side with the New Testament. He argues the newer texts present Jesus mainly as a revealer of knowledge, while the New Testament presents his death as a sacrifice for sin.
- N. T. Wright’s Judas and the Gospel of Jesus (2006) argues that the Gospel of Judas offers a Jesus who rescues people out of the world, unlike the Jesus of the Gospels, who comes as Lord of it.
In popular retellings, that history often becomes a simpler story: the real Jesus was hidden, and now he’s been found.
On the fringe. You’ve seen the thumbnails: “What your pastor never told you.” “The hidden Jesus they don’t want you to know.”
To be fair, sometimes pastors really didn’t tell people things they should have: church history, the hard texts, the church’s own sins. NewGrapes means to tell those things plainly. The counterfeit isn’t the untold fact. It’s the claim that salvation depends on the hidden layer, that the gospel you were given isn’t enough and the real Jesus lives behind a door only some can open.
In our own pews. Now the mirror. The Secret Christ shows up in Bible-loving places too:
- the “hidden code” in Scripture that only one teacher can crack;
- the private revelation that outranks the plain text;
- in Reformed circles, which is our own house, the quiet sense that the real Christians are the ones who read the right Puritans, know the Greek, or hold the right system.
Every one of these turns good gifts into a password. Study is a gift. Greek is a gift. Good theology is a gift. None of them is the door.
Why does the pattern pull so hard? Being an insider feels like belonging. And a secret can seem to explain a disappointment: maybe it didn’t work because nobody told you the real version.
Beside the real One
Now set the glass next to the emerald. What did Jesus himself say about secrets? When the high priest questioned him about his teaching, Jesus answered:
“I have spoken openly to the world. I have always taught in synagogues and in the temple, where all Jews come together. I have said nothing in secret.”
— John 18:20 (ESV)
The Secret Christ contradicts the real Christ’s own words.
The apostles wrote the same way:
- Luke wrote “an orderly account” from what “eyewitnesses and ministers of the word have delivered” (Luke 1:1–4, ESV).
- Peter: “For we did not follow cleverly devised myths… but we were eyewitnesses of his majesty” (2 Pet 1:16, ESV).
- Paul, on trial before a king: “this has not been done in a corner” (Acts 26:26, ESV).
Irenaeus drew the conclusion. The apostles preached the gospel “in public” and then “handed down to us in the Scriptures” (Against Heresies 3.1.1). And if they “had known hidden mysteries, which they were in the habit of imparting to the perfect apart and privily from the rest,” they would have given them to the very people they put in charge of the churches (3.3.1). The faith was never two-tiered.
But isn’t the Spirit still at work? Yes. The Spirit still works today, and real knowledge of Christ is a gift from above. When Peter confessed him, Jesus said, “flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my Father who is in heaven” (Matt 16:17, ESV). The Father does reveal, and what he reveals is the public Christ. Jonathan Edwards preached that there is “a spiritual and divine light, immediately imparted to the soul by God.” He called it “a true sense of the divine excellency of the things revealed in the word of God.” Then he guarded it:
“It reveals no new doctrine, it suggests no new proposition to the mind, it teaches no new thing of God, or Christ, or another world, not taught in the Bible, but only gives a due apprehension of those things that are taught in the word of God.”
— Jonathan Edwards, A Divine and Supernatural Light (1734)
Who receives it? Not only scholars. “Persons with an ordinary degree of knowledge,” Edwards wrote, “are capable of being taught by the Spirit of God, as well as learned men.” The Spirit doesn’t hand out secrets. He opens eyes to what has already been given in the open.
So does the believer have a secret at all? Charles Spurgeon says yes, and shows what kind. Preaching on “A spring shut up, a fountain sealed” (Song 4:12), he wrote:
“So is the heart of a believer when it is renewed by grace: there is a mysterious life within which no human skill can touch. It is a secret which no other man knoweth; nay, which the very man who is the possessor of it cannot tell to his neighbour. . . . It is a fountain bearing a particular mark—a king’s royal seal.”
— C. H. Spurgeon, Morning and Evening, Morning, November 18
The Christian’s secret is a life, not a lesson. No one gets in by learning the hidden layer, and no one can sell it to a neighbor, because the possessor can’t even explain it. It’s sealed by the King, not unlocked by the clever. And Spurgeon says whom it’s kept for: “It is a spring kept for Jesus.”
The best objection
“But Jesus did have secrets.” He did, and the Bible says so. Look closer.
The secret was given to fishermen. “To you has been given the secret of the kingdom of God, but for those outside everything is in parables” (Mark 4:11, ESV). “Privately to his own disciples he explained everything” (Mark 4:34, ESV). Who were “his own”? Fishermen and a tax collector, ordinary people. And they weren’t told to guard it. They were ordered to broadcast it: “What I tell you in the dark, say in the light, and what you hear whispered, proclaim on the housetops” (Matt 10:27, ESV).
Paul’s “secret wisdom” is the cross. Paul does write, “among the mature we do impart wisdom,” “a secret and hidden wisdom of God” (1 Cor 2:6–7, ESV). Second-century teachers seized on words like these for their “perfect.” But read the chapter. Paul’s content is “Jesus Christ and him crucified” (2:2). It is revealed “through the Spirit” (2:10), and Paul preached it openly to a whole, messy church. The secret was hidden before; now it is announced.
In Scripture, a secret is something God hides for a while and then proclaims. It never makes a permanent inner circle.
If you’ve been hurt
Some of us came looking for a hidden Jesus after a church wounded us. If that’s you, please hear this. Abuse and hypocrisy in churches are real sins, not misunderstandings. Christians, leaders included, are sometimes the bad guys in the story. God himself spoke against shepherds who use the flock: “Ah, shepherds of Israel who have been feeding yourselves! Should not shepherds feed the sheep?” (Ezek 34:2, ESV).
If what happened to you was abuse or a crime, please report it to the authorities. Getting help, including from the police, a counselor, or a doctor, is not a lack of faith.
You don’t need a secret to heal. You need the Shepherd. Go to Christ himself: “Come to me, all who labor and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest” (Matt 11:28, ESV), and “a bruised reed he will not break” (Matt 12:20, ESV). Open the Scriptures and read a Gospel straight through. And look for a safe, faithful local church: one that preaches the Bible, is honest about its leaders, and protects the vulnerable. That may be the church that hurt you, if it has truly repented and made things right, or it may be another. Don’t let the people who failed you keep you from the One who never will.
The public gospel
So here is the emerald, in the open, with names, places and witnesses attached. Paul wrote it down around AD 53–55, while many of the witnesses were still alive, and he called it “of first importance”:
“For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep. Then he appeared to James, then to all the apostles. Last of all, as to one untimely born, he appeared also to me.”
— 1 Corinthians 15:3–8 (ESV)
No password. No inner circle. A crucified and risen Lord, seen by hundreds and proclaimed to anyone who will listen.
Next, Part 2: The Split Christ, or what happens when Jesus is cut off from the God who made the world.
Sources
- Scripture: English Standard Version (Crossway, 2001/2016), checked at https://www.biblegateway.com (ESV). Matt 16:15–17; John 18:20; Deut 29:29; Luke 1:1–4; 2 Pet 1:16; Acts 26:26; Mark 4:11, 34; Matt 10:27; 1 Cor 2:2, 6–7, 10; Ezek 34:2; Matt 11:28; 12:20; 1 Cor 15:3–8.
- Date of 1 Corinthians: “c. A.D. 53–55,” ESV Global Study Bible, “Introduction to 1 Corinthians,” https://www.esv.org/resources/esv-global-study-bible/introduction-to-1-corinthians/
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies, trans. Alexander Roberts and William Rambaut, Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 1 (1885): Book 1, Preface (https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/0103100.htm); 3.1.1 (/0103301.htm); 3.3.1 (/0103303.htm).
- Nag Hammadi texts: The Apocryphon (Secret Book) of John, trans. Frederik Wisse, The Nag Hammadi Library: http://gnosis.org/naghamm/apocjn.html; The Gospel of Thomas, trans. Thomas O. Lambdin: http://gnosis.org/naghamm/gthlamb.html
- The Gospel of Judas, trans. Rodolphe Kasser, Marvin Meyer and Gregor Wurst, with François Gaudard. National Geographic, 2006. Translation text as released, April 2006: https://www.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/judastxt.pdf ; National Geographic, “Lost Gospel of Judas Revealed”: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/lost-gospel-judas-revealed-jesus-archaeology
- Pagels, Elaine. The Gnostic Gospels. Random House, 1979. Conclusion. Excerpt: New York Times, Nov 27, 1979, https://www.nytimes.com/1979/11/27/archives/the-gnostics-writings.html
- Bock, Darrell L. The Missing Gospels. Thomas Nelson, 2006. See also the DTS Voice review: https://voice.dts.edu/review/darrell-l-bock-the-missing-gospels/
- Wright, N. T. Judas and the Gospel of Jesus. Baker / SPCK, 2006. https://archive.org/details/judasgospelofjes0000wrig
- Spurgeon, C. H. Morning and Evening: Daily Readings, Morning, November 18 (Song of Solomon 4:12). CCEL: https://www.ccel.org/ccel/spurgeon/morneve.d1118am.html
- Edwards, Jonathan. A Divine and Supernatural Light (1734). Works vol. 2 text via Digital Puritan, https://www.digitalpuritan.net ; first edition at Evans/UMich.
- Noll, Mark A. America’s Book: The Rise and Decline of a Bible Civilization, 1794–1911. Oxford UP, 2022. Quoted: ch. 17, “Whose Bible?”, p. 368; ch. 22, opening of Part V, “After the Bible Civilization,” p. 473. Reviews: Sassi, JAH 110:4 (2024), https://doi.org/10.1093/jahist/jaad375 ; Christian Century, https://www.christiancentury.org/review/books/america-biblical
- Williams, Michael A. Rethinking “Gnosticism.” Princeton UP, 1996.
- King, Karen L. What Is Gnosticism? Harvard UP, 2003.
- Lee, Philip J. Against the Protestant Gnostics. Oxford UP, 1987.
- Bloom, Harold. The American Religion. Simon & Schuster, 1992. Part IV, chs. 12–14. See also the review in Ministry (Oct 1995), https://www.ministrymagazine.org/archive/1995/10/the-american-religion
Image made with AI tools. Words and Scripture checked by Justin.