On blame, ballots, and what Augustine told a church that was getting blamed for everything
In August of the year 410, Rome fell to the Visigoths.
Alaric’s army went through the city for three days. Rome hadn’t been taken by a foreign enemy in about 800 years. People fled across the sea to North Africa with whatever they could carry, and they brought a question with them.
Whose fault is this?
A lot of them had a ready answer. The Christians did it. Rome had turned away from the old gods and given itself to Christ, and look where that got us.
A bishop picks up his pen
Augustine was the bishop of Hippo, on the coast of North Africa. Those refugees were showing up in his part of the world, and so were the accusations. So he started writing an answer, and it took him the better part of thirteen years. We call it The City of God. It runs twenty-two books.
He didn’t write it to win a shouting match. He told the story as it actually was. Rome had suffered wars, plagues and civil bloodshed long before anyone in the Senate had heard of Jesus. The old gods hadn’t saved it then either. Then he went deeper and asked what kind of city a Christian really belongs to.
His answer is the line most people remember from the whole work:
“Two cities have been formed by two loves: the earthly by the love of self, even to the contempt of God; the heavenly by the love of God, even to the contempt of self.” (City of God XIV.28, Dods translation)
Every one of us lives in both cities for now. But only one of them is home.
Sixteen hundred years later
I’ve been trying to put my finger on something for about five years, and The City of God is a huge resource for it.
There’s a voice out there that says Christians are why this country is going downhill. Some of it comes from outside the church. Lately a good bit of it comes from inside. This election, I’ve seen Christians talk about other Christians who didn’t vote as if they’d failed a test of faith. Some of it got hateful.
That makes me very sad.
Now I must be clear. I’m not against America. I want my neighbors and my country to do well. And I’m not writing to tell anyone how to vote, or whether to. That isn’t the point.
The point is that a ballot was never the test of faith. Jesus already told us what the test is.
“By this all people will know that you are my disciples, if you have love for one another.” (John 13:35)
What the Bible actually says about cities
When we grab a verse to win an argument, we usually miss the whole picture. So let’s walk it in order.
Abraham left a city to follow God. “He was looking forward to the city that has foundations, whose designer and builder is God.” (Heb 11:10)
Centuries later, God’s people were carried off to Babylon, the most pagan city on earth. You’d think God would tell them to fight it or flee it. Instead He said, “Seek the welfare of the city where I have sent you into exile, and pray to the LORD on its behalf, for in its welfare you will find your welfare.” (Jer 29:7)
Then Jesus stood in front of Pilate, a Roman governor who had the power to kill Him, and said, “My kingdom is not of this world.” (John 18:36)
Peter wrote to Christians scattered across that same empire and called them “sojourners and exiles” (1 Pet 2:11). His instruction was short: “Honor everyone. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honor the emperor.” (1 Pet 2:17)
And it ends with a city coming down, not one we built going up. “And I saw the holy city, new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God.” (Rev 21:2)
From Abraham’s tent, to Babylon, to Pilate’s hall, to the New Jerusalem, the story is the same. We work hard for the good of the city we live in. We pray for it. But we never confuse it with home.
“For here we have no lasting city, but we seek the city that is to come.” (Heb 13:14)
So who’s to blame?
If the country is struggling, it isn’t because Christians followed Jesus too closely. Augustine would tell you it’s the old story of two loves. Love of self builds a city that always ends up crumbling. That was true of Rome, and it’s true of every nation since.
But Augustine wasn’t letting Christians off the hook either. The church is supposed to look different. When we treat each other like enemies over a ballot, we’re loving the earthly city more than we should, and the world notices.
“Who are you to pass judgment on the servant of another? It is before his own master that he stands or falls.” (Rom 14:4)
The answer isn’t to fight harder for the earthly city. It’s to remember which city we belong to. Then we go back to our neighbors, and to our own churches, and love them like it.
Go read the book
I’m not going to retell all twenty-two books here. I couldn’t do it justice, and I’d rather you went and read it yourself. The City of God is long, but it’s not locked away. You can start with Book I, where Augustine answers the people blaming the Christians for Rome. Then jump ahead to Book XIV, where the two loves come in. You’ll be surprised how much of it sounds like it was written this year.
Then decide for yourself.
Jesus asks each of us the same question He asked Peter: “But who do you say that I am?” (Matt 16:15). That question matters more than any election ever will.
So here’s mine for you, and for me. Which city are you really living for? And when the next election comes, will the other Christians on your street know you love them?
It’s not about us. It never was.
Sources
Sources
- Augustine, The City of God, trans. Marcus Dods (1871). Quote from Book XIV, chapter 28.
- Background on the sack of Rome (410) and the writing of City of God (c. 413–426): Augustine’s own preface to Book I and his Retractations II.43.
This article was written with AI assistance, reviewed and approved by Justin Morgan. Scripture quotations are from the ESV.